Collecting

Grading

Before you pay to slab a sticker, check which version of the card you have. PSA treats the finish on the back and the words printed on it as different cards, and off-center borders on the front are the most common reason a sticker misses a high grade.

Which card do you have?

Turn it over first. Original Series 1 cards came with two back finishes, glossy and matte, and collectors pay more for glossy. Hold two side by side under a lamp: the glossy back shines and the matte one stays flat. PSA lists them as separate cards, so a glossy copy of 1a goes down as "Nasty Nick Glossy" and builds its own price history.

Then read the back. Six cards in the first series, 5a, 5b, 8a, 8b, 29a and 29b, also exist with a checklist printed on the back, and PSA keeps those apart too, in matte and glossy. So 8a Adam Bomb, like the other five, has four versions on a PSA label: matte, glossy, and each of those with a checklist back.

Look for stars. On many of the early cards, Topps printed a single asterisk on the copyright line from one printing plate and two asterisks from the other, by most accounts so it could trace printing problems back to a plate. Collectors chasing the full variation set want both. PSA's list for the 1985 stickers does not separate the star versions, so if the star matters to you, read the back through the slab before you buy.

The second series has variations of its own. 42a Patty Putty and 42b Muggin' Megan have backs that read either "Sneak Award" or "Spaz Award." 49b Schizo Fran was replaced partway through production by Fran Fran, and the checklist cards 46a to 47b that named her were changed with her. PSA lists the award backs and both versions of those checklists as separate cards.

What a grader looks at

Four things: centering, corners, edges and surface. A card's grade roughly follows its worst one, so a single soft corner holds back a card that is perfect everywhere else. Many GPK cards came out of the pack clean. Centering is where they usually fall short, because 1980s Topps stickers were often printed well off.

To check it, measure the border on the left and the right, add the two together, divide one side by the total and multiply by 100. Do the same top to bottom. These are the front centering figures in PSA's published standards, with the back allowed 90/10 from PSA 9 down:

  • PSA 10: about 55/45 to 60/40 on the front, and 75/25 on the back
  • PSA 9: about 60/40 to 65/35
  • PSA 8: about 65/35 to 70/30
  • PSA 7: about 70/30 to 75/25
  • PSA 6: 80/20
  • PSA 5: 85/15

A card that is clean everywhere but off-center can come back with OC after the number, PSA's off-center qualifier, and buyers pay less for it than for the same grade without it. Measure before you send it.

Stickers are not cards

These are stickers on a card backing. The sticker can lift at a corner, curl or crease where it has started to come away. Do not press a lifting corner back down and do not try to peel and re-stick one.

Wax stains from the pack are common on 1985 cards. Leave them. PSA sends back cards it judges to have been cleaned without a grade, and its standards name using a solution to remove wax, candy, gum or tobacco stains as cleaning. It will not grade a trimmed card either.

Is it worth grading?

Compare what the card is worth raw with what slabbed copies are asking, then take off what grading costs at the service level you would use. PSA's prices change, so check its site on the day.

In the eBay listings we pulled in November 2026, counting every finish together, Ray Decay 2b was asking about $100 in a PSA 8 and $200 in a PSA 9. Nasty Nick 1a was asking about $520 in a PSA 6 and $1,800 in a PSA 8. For most of the series a PSA 6 or 7 asks little more than a nice raw copy, so grading pays on the big names and on cards that should come back 9 or 10.

Every kid page in Original Series 1 and 2 carries a grade-by-grade table of eBay asking prices and links to PSA's own population and sales pages for each version of the card. An asking price is not a sale price, and PSA's pages show what slabs actually sold for, so check those too.

Logging your slabs

When a card comes back, add it to your binder: the card, the grader, the grade on the label and the cert number. A PSA or CGC cert links to the grader's own lookup, so anyone you trade with can check it.

Prices by grade for every 1985 card are in the price guide. PSA's grading standards: psacard.com.